EIPIP Meeting 102 #326
Description
Date and Time
March 27 April 10, 2024 at 17:30 UTC
Location
Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel
YouTube Recording: EIPIP Meetings
Agenda
1. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics
Edit to Final Proposals
- Update ERC-2135: fix some typos ethereum/ERCs#304
- Update ERC-7231: Corrected typos inside document lines. ethereum/ERCs#317
- Update ERC-5585: ERC-721 NFT Authorization ethereum/ERCs#367
- Update ERC-2098: variable v is not right in example. ethereum/ERCs#342
- Update ERC-20: Fix broken link on erc-20.md ethereum/ERCs#324
Potential Spam
PR for review by RIP Editors
Community proposals added to Issues
- Proposal: Living EIP's MUST contain revision history or some versioning sub identifier ethereum/EIPs#8308
- Add (or change to) bibtex citation for EIPs ethereum/EIPs#8292
- Separate EIPs and ERCs ethereum/EIPs#8284
- Add (Last) Updated information to the EIP/ERC page ethereum/EIPs#8282
- based ethereum address decentralized IP address, Abolish ipv4 and ipv6 ethereum/EIPs#8269
How to lower the number of open Issues & Pull Requests?
Call for Input
| Call For Input | Status | Inclination/Result | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| #317 | Closed | @SamWilsn: "I don't really see a clear consensus. @g11tech is likely in favour since he made this proposal, and @lightclient has clearly expressed his opposition. I'm going to close this as rejected, but am fine with re-opening if there's more discussion to be had." | March 20th, 2024 |
| #318 | Closed | This is past the deadline, and the general consensus appears to be to not merge this PR. | March 20th, 2024 |
| #321 | Closed | @SamWilsn: "See #291 (comment) for a bit more detail on my reasoning, but the short form is Final means Final, and we only allow updates to correct errors in the specification." | March 22nd, 2024 |
| #320 | Open | @g11tech , is the only editor responded and is in favor. Didn't receive any response from any other editor | March 21st, 2024 |
| #325 | Open | @lightclient @SamWilsn are in favor. @xinbenlv seems to be coming around for this, but have suggestions to have policy defined around such issues | April 7th, 2024 |
| #327 | Open | @SamWilsn is in favor, requires input from other editors | April 12th, 2024 |
| #329 | Open | requires input from other editors | April 29th, 2024 |
| #331 | Open | @SamWilsn & @lightclient are in favor of merging this pull request. requires input from other editors | April 29th, 2024 |
| #332 | Open | @g11tech is against entertaining such PRs and closing them off, requires input from other editors | May 8, 2024 |
2. Other discussions and updates from past meetings
- Web Page Rendering to include EIPs, ERCs, RIPs
- Working Group Charter
3. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.
4. EIP Editing Office Hour
5. Review action items from earlier meetings
- Summary meeting 101
Action items from the last meeting - Update ERC-6672: Update erc-6672.md ethereum/ERCs#285
No specific Call for Input but @xinbenlv will create a Call for Input for general policy around updating authors for Final EIPs. - Update ERC-7201: Fix solidity formula ethereum/ERCs#201
@SamWilsn will create a Call for Input for this Pull Request
Next Meeting date & time
May 01, 2024 at 17:30 UTC